# Reviewed fictional comparison

Constructed documents and chat-assisted editorial review. Not real vendor information, independent model accuracy, buying advice or market evidence.

Budget: USD 300 including tax and editable project files. Four clips.

| Supplier | Term | Status | Reviewed statement | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Alder | scope | supported | Four clips, each at most 45 seconds. | A:L02 |
| Alder | price | conflicting_statements | Formal quote USD 240 excluding tax; later planning estimate USD 280 excluding tax. No revised formal quote issued. | A:L03, E:L02, E:L03 |
| Alder | delivery | conditional | Five business days in the quote; seven calendar days only a possibility subject to booking confirmation. | A:L04, E:L04 |
| Alder | revisions | supported | One consolidated revision round. | A:L05 |
| Alder | project_files | unknown | Absent from the original quote; separate quote offered without an amount. | A:L06, E:L05 |
| Alder | licenses | condition | Client supplies permitted fonts and music. | A:L07 |
| Birch | scope | supported | Four clips, each at most 45 seconds; minimum order four. | B:L02 |
| Birch | price | derived | USD 360 for four clips, including tax. | B:L02, B:L03 |
| Birch | delivery | condition | Seven calendar days after approved script and all assets; booking availability still needs confirmation. | B:L04, B:L07 |
| Birch | revisions | supported | Two consolidated revision rounds. | B:L05 |
| Birch | project_files | condition | Included, with third-party fonts/music excluded from transfer. | B:L06 |
| Birch | licenses | condition | Separate permission needed for third-party fonts and music. | B:L06 |

## Decision
No offer is confirmed to meet all requirements. No winner or purchase authorization.

Alder all-in cost: unknown. Birch stated fee: USD 90 × 4 = USD 360 including tax; USD 60 above the cap. Third-party permissions are not assumed free.

## Questions
- Alder: please confirm one formal four-clip price including tax and editable project files.
- Alder: can you commit to seven calendar days after the approved script and all assets, and confirm the booking?
- Both: which third-party assets require permission, and what project files can actually be delivered?
- Birch: the stated four-clip fee is USD 60 over our cap. Is there an explicitly revised scope/price? Do not assume a discount.